The squad has been announced, 14 man squad with Jamie Dalrymple called up, Liam Plunkett is suffering from a side injury and struggling to be fit.
A Strauss (capt), M Trescothick, A Cook, K Pietersen, P Collingwood, I Bell, G Jones (wkt), L Plunkett, M Hoggard, S Harmison, J Lewis, M Panesar, S Mahmood, J Dalrymple
Who would Dalrymple replace if he was to play?
Surely even on a supposed spinning wicket we would'nt play Dalrymple, Monty and only 2 recognised seamers? Or is it time for Paul Collingwood to stake his claim as a genuinly useful test allrounder?
Mushy is in a squad of 12 for the Sussex game today, probably indicates that he won't feature for Pakistan.
I am worried about our tail, its certainly an issue and one the selectors seem to ignore.
It could have possibly been helped if Monty was dropped and Dalrymple had played, or even someone like Clarke too Plunkett's posuition, not sure what Clarkes bowling is like though.
Or both changes! Then Geraint Jones could have batted no.9!
Even as a Surrey supporter I wouldn't say Rikki Clarke's bowling is good enough to take Test wickets for England. He could only play as one of four seamers. I would like to see Collingwood doing more bowling while Flintoff is absent.
Pakistan line up: Younis Khan, Imran Farhat, Faisal Iqbal, Mohammad Yousuf, Mohammad Sami, Inzamam -ul-Haq, Abdul Razzaq, Kamran Akmal, Shahid Afridi, Umar Gul, Danish Kaneria
Logged
wccc. The best team in the world
The Ideal England Team: Hick, Solanki, Batty, Davies, Kabir Ali, Mitchell, Moore, Sillence, Khalid, Moeen Ali, wccc
Even as a Surrey supporter I wouldn't say Rikki Clarke's bowling is good enough to take Test wickets for England. He could only play as one of four seamers. I would like to see Collingwood doing more bowling while Flintoff is absent.
Don't know enough about Clarke but i agree with you on Collingwood, if he could turn himself into that 4th seamer with Flintoff and two others, we could be in business.
I don't understand why he does'nt bowl more at test level.